How to Thicken Sauce: Cornstarch, Flour & Substitute Ingredients Explained

Sauce is a key element to most recipes and can even make or break a dish — however, when the consistency of the sauce is too thin (we’re looking at you, gravy) it can disrupt the flavor, moisture and even texture of your favorite foods.

The good ol’ spoon trick can determine if your sauce is too thick or thin. All you have to do is dip the back of a spoon into the sauce, and if it is smooth and velvety then your sauce is cooked to perfection.

But what if your sauce isn’t the right consistency?

There are several methods if you are unsure how to thicken sauce. You can add tomato paste to tomato-based sauces for extra texture or create a roux with flour, or even reduce some of the liquid.

From flour to arrowroot, let’s review some of the common thickening agents.

Table of Contents:

• How to thicken sauce by reducing liquid
• How to thicken sauce with cornstarch
• How to thicken sauce with flour
• How to thicken sauce with egg yolks
• How to thicken sauce with butter
• How to thicken sauce with arrowroot
• How to thicken sauce with tomato paste
• How to thicken sauce with beurre manié

How to make a sauce thicker

If your sauce isn’t thick enough for your liking, you can perform a few methods to add more thickness. 

Reduction is one of the easiest ways to thicken sauce because you just reduce the amount of liquid with a few extra minutes of boiling. You can keep the sauce on a full boil or simmer, but make sure you leave the sauce uncovered to let the steam evaporate.

You can also thicken the sauce by adding additional ingredients like flour or egg yolks. These methods require a few extra steps, but the results are worth it. 

Keep reading to discover how to thicken sauce with readily available ingredients.

Different ways to thicken sauce

Reduction isn’t the only way to thicken sauce. While flour is often used, there are plenty of alternatives.

How to thicken sauce by reducing liquid

As we mentioned before, the easiest way to make a sauce thicker is by reducing the amount of liquid. This can be done by bringing the uncovered sauce to a medium or full boil. 

By reducing the amount of liquid in the sauce you are also shifting the flavors. Let your sauce boil for two to three minutes and check the thickness and taste in regular intervals.

Why it works: As existing water evaporates the liquid becomes denser and the compounds of your mixture solidify.

When to use it: Reducing liquid is best for sauces that are slightly too thin like marinara sauces, BBQ glazes and braising liquids.

Steps to use it: 

1. Let your sauce boil for two to three minutes
2. Check the thickness and taste in regular intervals
3. Coat the back of a spoon with sauce to test the thickness 
4. Season your sauce after you have the desired thickness to concentrate the flavors

How to thicken sauce with cornstarch

Cornstarch is a great gluten-free alternative to thicken sauce. This thickening agent is easily available and fairly inexpensive.

When using cornstarch to thicken sauce it’s important to watch your measurements to avoid thickening your sauce too much.

Cornstarch tends to break down acid, so avoid using it to thicken acidic sauces.

Why it works: Cornstarch is widely available, translucent and won’t alter the color or flavor of your sauces. When you heat this carbohydrate derived from corn it becomes a thick, gelatinous consistency.

When to use it: Use cornstarch for clear sauces like stocks or soy-based liquids. You can also use cornstarch to thicken pudding and custard, stir fry, gravies and curry sauces.

Steps to use it:

1. Add 1 tablespoon of cornstarch to 1 tablespoon of cold water
2. Whisk the cornstarch and water together to create a slurry
3. Pour your slurry into sauce on medium heat
4. Bring the sauce to a boil for one minute
5. Coat the back of a spoon with the sauce to see if it is thick enough

How to thicken sauce with flour

If you don’t have a gluten sensitivity, then you can thicken your sauce with flour by creating a slurry or roux. 

The roux ratio is equal parts flour and a source of fat — most people use butter. A slurry is flour combined with water to help thicken sauce.

Why it works: When you add flour into your sauce, the starches expand to help add more thickness to your liquid.

When to use it: Use flour to thicken soups, gravy, dairy-based sauces and stews. 

Steps to create a roux: 

1. Warm butter over medium heat
2. Add an equal amounts of flour as butter to the saucepan 
3. Whisk until you create a thick, golden paste
4. Add your roux to your sauce and mix until well combined
5. Test the thickness of your sauce with the back of a spoon

Steps to create a slurry: 

1. Add 2 tablespoons of flour for every 1/4 cup of cold water
2. Whisk until slurry is smooth
3. Add slurry mixture to sauce and heat over medium
4. Stir until you reach your desired thickness
5. Test your sauce by coating it with the back of your spoon

How to thicken sauce with egg yolks

Did you know that you can add one or two egg yolks to your sauce to sub for cornstarch to increase the thickness?

You can add more yolks depending on how much sauce you are making, but a good rule of thumb is to start off with one or two. To avoid egg yolks from curdling, you can add hot sauce or a small amount of the sauce you are cooking.

Why it works: The protein in eggs helps thicken sauce when heated.

When to use it: Add egg yolks to pasta sauces, salad dressings, cream-based sauces and custards.

Steps to use it: 

1. In a bowl, separate egg yolks from the whites
2. Add in a small amount of the sauce to temper the egg yolks from curdling
3. Whisk the egg mixture into the rest of the sauce
4. Dip your spoon into the sauce to test its thickness

How to thicken sauce with butter

Give your sauce an extra boost with the assistance of butter. This food-thickening agent should be completed toward the end of cooking because the butter will break if exposed to high heat.

Make sure to start off with only a small amount of butter to avoid adding too much moisture to the sauce.

Why it works: A slice of butter will slightly thicken the sauce while adding richness and creating a glossy texture.

When to use it: Add butter to pan and pasta sauces that don’t require much thickness.

Steps to use it: 

1. Take sauce off of high heat
2. Add a tablespoon of butter and into the sauce
3. Swirl the butter in the sauce to create more depth
4. Test your sauce by coating the back of a spoon
5. Add another tablespoon of butter if your sauce isn’t thick enough

How to thicken sauce with arrowroot

Arrowroot is a gluten-free thickening agent that is similar to cornstarch, but comes from the tropical plant arrowroot tuber.

You can use arrowroot as a cornstarch replacement, but avoid adding it to dairy-based sauces because it creates a slimy consistency.

Why it works: Arrowroot thickens identical to cornstarch, but can thicken sauce even at a lower temperature. It also doesn’t break when combined with acids, unlike cornstarch.

When to use it: Use arrowroot for stocks, soy-based liquids and acidic sauces.

Steps to use it:

1. In a bowl, add 1 tablespoon of arrowroot to 1 tablespoon of cold water
2. Whisk the arrowroot and water together to create a slurry
3. Add slurry to your sauce and put on medium heat
4. Boil the sauce for one minute
5. Check the thickness of your sauce by coating the back of a spoon with it

How to thicken sauce with tomato paste

You can thicken sauce with tomato paste at the start of your recipe to ensure a perfect consistency. When you heat tomato paste, it caramelizes the sugars and releases oils.

It’s not recommended to add tomato paste to dairy-based sauces because it could alter the taste.

Why it works: Tomato paste has a naturally thick texture, so when it’s added to liquid it acts as a thickening agent.

When to use it: Add tomato paste to tomato sauces, tomato soup, brown sauces and beef stews.

Steps to use it:

1. Pour a can of tomato paste into your saucepan
2. Mix the sauce until the tomato paste is well combined
3. Cook your sauce on medium heat
4. Dip the back on a spoon into the sauce to check the thickness

How to thicken sauce with beurre manié

You can thicken sauce with a kneaded butter mixture, called beurre manié. This process is similar to a roux, but you create the mixture off of heat.

Why it works: The softened butter and flour mixture kneaded into a dough consistency creates the perfect amount of thickness to any sauce, stew or soup.

When to use it: You can thicken any sauce, soup or stew with this method.

Steps to use it:

1. Combine equal parts of softened butter and flour in a bowl
2. Knead the butter until the texture is similar to modeling clay
3. Add your beurre manié to your sauce
4. Whisk the sauce on medium heat until well combined
5. Continue cooking your sauce until it is done
6. Check the thickness of the sauce by coating the back of a spoon with it 

How to thicken sauce using cornstarch

Recipe by InstacartCourse: RecipesCuisine: SaucesDifficulty: Easy

Servings

Varies

servings

Prep time

5

minutes

Cooking time

Total time

10

minutes

Cornstarch is a gluten-free alternative to thicken sauce that won’t alter the color or flavor.

Ingredients

• 1 tablespoon of cornstarch

• 1 tablespoon of cold water

• Additional recommended supplies

• Saucepan

• Whisk

• Large spoon

Directions

• Add 1 tablespoon of cornstarch to 1 tablespoon of cold water
• Whisk the cornstarch and water together to create a slurry
• Pour your slurry into sauce on medium heat
• Bring the sauce to a boil for one minute
• Coat the back of a spoon with the sauce to see if it is thick enough

Tools for thickening sauce

Good news! You do not need expensive or elaborate tools for thickening sauce.

Here are a few tools you can use to perform these cooking tasks:

• Bowl: Make sure the bowl is large enough to avoid any spillage.
• Whisk: This cooking utensil is perfect for blending together your food-thickening agents and your sauce seamlessly.
• Saucepan: Choose a saucepan that is large enough to cook your sauce without spillage.
• Thickening agent: You will need butter, flour, cornstarch or whichever thickening agent you choose to use.

How to thicken sauce: FAQ

Still unsure how to thicken sauces? We answered some of your burning questions below.

Saucy final thoughts

Now that you know how to thicken sauce, it’s time to put these agents to work. Remember you can use flour to thicken sauce if you do not have a gluten sensitivity, or you can use cornstarch or arrowroot as a substitute thickening agent.

If you find yourself in a pickle and are in need of a food-thickening agent, you can place a same-day order with Instacart. Our team will deliver your groceries to your doorstep without the hassle of going to the store.

Instacart has all of the tools and ingredients you need to whip up the tastiest sauce with the perfect consistency. Place your order today!

Instacart

Author

Instacart is the leading grocery technology company in North America, partnering with more than 1,400 national, regional, and local retail banners to deliver from more than 80,000 stores across more than 14,000 cities in North America. To read more Instacart posts, you can browse the company blog or search by keyword using the search bar at the top of the page.